Visa and Mastercard swipe fee settlement: judge holds off on ruling. What it means for small businesses

- Judge Brian Cogan heard arguments on final approval on November 16 and did not rule; he granted preliminary approval in June.
- The deal would cut credit card swipe fees by 0.1 percentage point for five years and hold standard consumer card rates to 1.25% for eight years.
- Merchants could decline premium rewards cards and commercial cards and would gain more room to surcharge and offer discounts.
- Walmart, the National Retail Federation and convenience-store groups object, saying the relief is too small.
- Check your effective processing rate and shop your processor now rather than waiting for the court.
A federal judge in Brooklyn heard arguments on November 16 over whether to give final approval to Visa and Mastercard's settlement with U.S. merchants over card swipe fees, and ended the hearing without ruling. If he approves it, most small businesses would see a small, temporary cut in what they pay to accept credit cards, plus new rights to turn away some of the most expensive cards.
What happened?
U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan heard Visa, Mastercard and the merchants' class lawyers ask him to approve the deal, while Walmart, the National Retail Federation and convenience-store groups urged him to reject it. Reuters reported that slightly more than 1,000 objections have been filed. Cogan, who granted preliminary approval in June, did not decide. He told the court that rejecting the deal would mean a trial, which he described as a "protracted process."
The case began in 2005. A different judge rejected an earlier, $30 billion version of the settlement in June 2024 as too small. The settlement covers a class of more than 12 million merchants.
What would the settlement change for small businesses?
Based on Reuters and Payments Dive reporting, the main terms are:
- A small fee cut. Credit card swipe fees would drop by 0.1 percentage point (10 basis points) for five years.
- A rate on standard cards. Interchange on standard consumer credit cards would be set at no more than 1.25% for eight years.
- The right to say no to some cards. Merchants could decline premium consumer cards, including rewards cards, and commercial cards, while still taking standard cards from the same network. That is a break from the long-standing "honor all cards" rule.
- More room to surcharge and discount. Payments Dive reported that merchants would gain new rights to add surcharges and offer discounts to steer customers toward cheaper cards.
The merchants' lawyers say the deal is worth about $38 billion in savings through 2031, an estimate prepared by economist Joseph Stiglitz and another expert.
Why are merchants still objecting?
Opponents say the relief is too small and too short. Reuters reported that swipe fees averaged 2.36% in 2025, citing Merchants Payments Coalition figures, so a 0.1-point cut barely moves the total. A lawyer for the convenience-store trade group NACS and Circle K argued that commercial and premium cards, which carry the higher fees, make up more than 90% of the card market, so the 1.25% rate would apply to only a sliver of transactions. Objectors also argue that the right to refuse rewards cards means little in practice, because so much spending runs on them. Visa and Mastercard's lawyers argue the deal brings real change for the networks.
What does it mean for your cash flow?
The direct savings are modest. As a simple example, a business running $50,000 a month in credit card sales would save about $50 a month from a 0.1-point cut, before any other changes. That helps, but it will not fix a tight month.
The bigger levers are the new acceptance and surcharge rights, and those come with trade-offs. Declining premium cards or adding a surcharge could push some customers to pay another way, or to shop somewhere else. State surcharging laws and card network rules still apply, so check both before you change anything at the register.
Timing also matters. Nothing changes until the judge rules. Do not build this year's budget around lower fees.
If your business carries a cash advance repaid as a share of your card sales, your card volume affects how fast you pay it down. Changing how you accept cards could shift that pace, so talk to your funder first. Our guide to how a merchant cash advance works explains how card-split repayment works.
What owners can do now
- Pull your last three processing statements. Find your effective rate: total fees divided by total card sales. That number tells you what a 0.1-point change is worth to you.
- See which cards your customers use. Many processors break out rewards, commercial and standard cards. If most of your volume is premium, the 1.25% rate will matter less to you.
- Shop your processor. You do not need to wait for the court. A quote from another processor, or a switch to a flat or interchange-plus plan, can save more than this settlement would.
- Hold off on surcharges until rules are final. Check your state's law and your processor's terms first.
- Line up cheaper credit before you need it. If processing costs squeeze your margins, a bank line of credit or an SBA loan usually costs far less than a cash advance, which is expensive short-term money. Compare the two in our guide to lines of credit versus cash advances, and use our factor rate to APR calculator to see the real cost of any offer.
Sources
- Visa, Mastercard urge approval of $38 billion swipe fee settlement · Reuters via The Spokesman-Review
- Visa and Mastercard Hearing Puts Premium Card Pilots on the Line · PYMNTS
- Visa, Mastercard urge court to approve fee settlement · Payments Dive
- Visa and Mastercard Seek to Close 20-Year Antitrust Case With $38 Billion Deal · Finance Magnates
- More than 1,000 Merchants Urge Judge to Reject Flawed Visa/Mastercard Swipe Fee Settlement · Merchants Payments Coalition
Related guides
What is a merchant cash advance? A plain-English guideBusiness line of credit vs. merchant cash advanceThis brief summarizes public reporting and is general information, not financial or legal advice. Daybook Capital is a broker, not a lender or funder; each funding partner sets its own criteria, pricing and terms.