Broker vs. marketplace vs. direct lender: where should you get business funding?
Short answer: a direct lender reviews your application and funds you itself. A marketplace is software that matches one application to several lenders. A broker is a person or firm that reviews your business, sends your file to funders that fit, and helps you compare the offers. Lenders pay marketplaces and brokers when a deal funds, so a good broker or marketplace costs you nothing to apply. Go direct if you already know which lender fits. Use a marketplace to browse on your own. Use a broker if you want help reading offers or your file is harder to place.
Disclosure: Daybook Capital is a broker. We've tried to describe all three fairly.
How do the three compare?
| Direct lender | Marketplace | Broker | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides on your application | The lender | Each lender it sends you to | Each funding partner it sends you to |
| How many offers you see | One | Several, matched by software | Several, chosen by a person |
| Who you talk to | The lender's staff | Mostly online; some offer phone support | A broker who knows your file |
| How it's paid | Interest, factor rate and fees | Commission from the lender | Commission from the funding partner |
| Cost to you to apply | Usually free | Usually free | Should be free; avoid upfront fees |
| Best when | You know which lender fits | You want to browse quickly | You want help comparing, or banks said no |
How do brokers and marketplaces get paid?
Both are usually paid by the lender or funding partner as a percentage of what funds. That's why applying is free. Because their pay grows with the amount, ask for the total repayment on every offer and compare offers side by side, not just the payment. Our MCA vs. loan calculator puts two offers next to each other.
What are the red flags with any funding company?
- A fee before you've seen a written offer. Some states ban upfront fees by loan brokers outright; Florida is one. Daybook never charges you to apply. Funding partners may charge their own fees, and they must tell you before you agree to anything.
- "Guaranteed approval." No honest broker or lender can promise it before reviewing your file.
- Pressure to sign the same day. A real offer will still be there tomorrow.
- No total repayment in writing. Several states, including California and New York, now require cost disclosures on many commercial financing offers.
- Stacking without a plan. A second advance on top of an open one doubles your daily payments. See second merchant cash advances.
When should you go to a direct lender?
If your bank already knows you, or you've compared before and know which lender fits, going direct removes a step. SBA loans and bank lines of credit are usually cheapest, but take longer and ask for more paperwork.
When does a marketplace make sense?
If your business is straightforward (steady revenue, decent credit, a few years in business) and you're comfortable reading offers yourself, a marketplace lets you see several options quickly. Our comparison of Lendio, Fundera, Nav and Biz2Credit covers the big ones.
When does a broker make sense?
A broker helps most when a bank has turned you down, your deposits are uneven or seasonal, or you've received an offer and want someone to explain what it really costs. A broker should be able to tell you why each funder is a fit and show the total cost of every offer.
Daybook Capital works this way. Most of our funding partners look for at least 12 months in business and $15,000 or more in monthly deposits, and every credit profile is considered. See how it works or start an application.
Frequently asked questions
Do business funding brokers charge fees?
Reputable brokers are paid by the funding partner, so applying should cost you nothing. Be cautious of anyone asking for a fee before you've seen a written offer; some states ban upfront fees by loan brokers.
Is it better to go directly to a lender?
If you already know which lender fits, going direct removes a step. If you don't, a marketplace or broker lets you compare several offers from one application.
Are marketplaces like Lendio brokers?
They work similarly: they're paid by lenders when a deal funds. The difference is mostly in how much is automated versus handled by a person.
This article is general information, not financial or legal advice. Daybook Capital is a broker, not a lender or funder. Each funding partner sets its own criteria, pricing, terms and fees.